Facebook and Rapport

10 Sep

Facebook appears to be the latest and best thing in the World Wide Web right now. This poses a challenge to libraries.   For instance, while many libraries are exploring library search applications, others are concerned that students do not want their librarians in their social space.

While some critics will tell you that Library 2.0 is no different from previous service models, others will say that services like Facebook pose a problem largely because of library culture. I concur with the latter view, not because I think Library 2.0 strategies are always better, but because Library 2.0 strategies require librarians to unlearn certain things in order to be truly effective.

Ok. So let me start with the Facebook library search application. It is fine, but my opinion is that few people besides librarians are going to add the applications to their profiles. The technology is Web 2.0, but the strategy is still Library 1.0. Why? Because the model is still, “I am librarian. I can help. Come to me (ie. my Facebook page) and I will serve.” The applications, though offering marginally better service for little cost, are not taking advantage of what Facebook offers its clients.

A Facebook application should be something your average person wants to show their friends. The most obvious application, therefore, is something that shows the books you enjoy reading. Unfortunately, Books iRead already beat us to that punch. But thinking in a Facebook way requires some innovation — we need to give something with which the user will identify. Off the top of my head, how about an application that provides a cartoony-like character that identifies the user as a certain kind of geek, according to a specific discipline? Then, the cartoon offers a series of articles, books and websites that display the geeky interest? For instance, an Anthro geek would have a series of citations related to Anthropology. This avenue is cheekier, more likely to be applied to a user’s page, and, in the end, a totally foreign approach to service for librarians.   Another possibility is to offer people a Dewey or LC code — though you might get into trouble for that.

Consider this a challenge, but I’d be surprised to see a library come up with anything comparable to these ideas in the near future. Given time, some developer may steal these ideas though (or something like them) — in fact, similar applications  may exist already. A library would be concerned about its “professional” image; a developer would just make it happen — assuming the idea is feasible and sound. A librarian-entrepreneur might make it happen outside of the confines of their library, but I’ve already discussed that issue.

I do not intend this to be another slight on “non-hip” or “change resisting” librarians. This is library culture. It is the stuff that has helped us survive for decades or even longer. But it is not a library 2.0 strategy. I am not convinced that a Library 2.0 strategy is necessarily what we ought to be doing, but what we are pretending is library 2.0 is actually not very.

Facebook, Librarians and Culture

In the end, the reason students will say they do not want to see librarians and educators on Facebook is that the culture of Libraries clashes with the culture of Facebook. If we approach Facebook using our typical library assumptions and with little awareness of typical Facebook assumptions, we will be intruders on the Facebook territory. If we can establish rapport with the Facebook community, we will matter to them.

Culture is important to any community interaction, and Facebook is a complex web of community interaction. I have a Facebook profile. It would be fairly difficult to understand which friends are important to me. Some “friends” are actually “friends” in my world. Others are merely people I’ve encountered in my travels through life. Some are old high school buddies I’m keeping track of. Others are just people who “friended” me and I was too polite to just say “leave me alone.”

That said, to say that Facebook does not have a culture would be wrong. Here are some basic Facebook traits based on my own observations.

  • The Facebook model affirms extroversion. Even if you are the sort to have only a few good friends in your life, that attitude will not get you far on Facebook. How can you tell? Well, look at how the Facebook application assumes you want more friends. Not only that — it assumes that your friends want the same Facebook applications.   It even assumes that when you remove a relationship detail on your profile, it’s because of a breakup.
  • Unlike MySpace, the Facebook model tries to set itself apart from the World Wide Web. The goal is not to be “out there” but “in here” — “here” being Facebook itself. Evidence? Look at the login screen — very plain, divulging very little about what’s going on inside. Apparently this is changing somewhat, but the fact that this is considered a change tells you that the assumption exists.
  • Facebook assumes that its users want their attention diverted. “Poke” exists for no other reason than to divert your attention to your friends. A good number of Facebook applications are actually advanced “poking” utilities. For instance there is “superpoke” which lets you slap instead of poke. There are also Pirate and Jedi related pokes for people to play around with.

For libraries to engage Facebook requires rapport. Establishing such a rapport takes at least four things.

  1. Understand the culture of the Facebook universe (covered in part above)
  2. Understand the bits of the Facebook universe that clash with library culture. For instance, Facebook wants the World Wide Web to be “outside” Facebook; libraries want to try and bring such resources “in.”
  3. Use cross-cultural communication techniques to put the library message/service on the same wavelength as Facebook.
  4. Do the above without sacrificing the things that make libraries unique and important.

In more specific terms, though — when engaging a service on Facebook libraries should:

  • Aim toward extroversion — the goal is not only to be friendly, and approachable, but inquisitive — chatty even. Banter is what Facebook is all about. You need to ask people questions and understand what it is they like. You also need to ask yourself, “how is a library search box extroverted?”
  • Consider that your staff are probably already out there on your behalf. For instance, a Halifax Public Libraries group already exists and a number of staff are connected already.
  • Pay close attention to the Terms of Use on Facebook. You do not want to find your applications turned off and rejected because they apply principles foreign to the service. Steve Lawson noticed a sudden scare when the first library applications for Facebook came out.
  • Applications are bits of information that you want Facebook users to put on their profiles. To put something on my profile, I want to identify with it and/or I want my friends to know I identify with it.
  • Be fun — Banks don’t offer loans on Facebook (yet). Accountants don’t do your taxes on Facebook (yet). If you have a Facebook strategy, it has to be a relatively non-business-like strategy.
About these ads

30 Responses to “Facebook and Rapport”

  1. Emily B. September 12, 2007 at 1:46 pm #

    Good points… I think one way that libraries can be “present” in Facebook without intruding on the personal connections by “friending” student/patrons/etc. is by creating groups and posting information to the groups. Groups with funny names are especially good, since some people participate in groups and others just link to them. Since they can be used either way, groups match the “seek us out” model that most library users are comfortable with much more effectively than the facebook feed that passes information back & forth with much less control.

  2. Ryan Deschamps November 23, 2013 at 12:47 pm #

    Reblogged this on The Other Librarian and commented:

    This came up in previous discussions recently, so I thought I’d share them. This blog is pretty much closed, but maybe I’ll bring it out again for reblogs.


  1. Facebook and Libraries : David Lee King - September 11, 2007

    [...] Deschamps at The Other Librarian recently posted about Facebook and libraries. It’s a thought-provoking article – go read it! Here are some tidbits from the [...]

  2. Facebook och biblioteket « [Omv] Lite IT - Om kultur och bibliotek i interaktionssamhället - September 18, 2007

    [...] on september 18th, 2007. Ryan Deschampes skriver på sin blogg The Other Librarian om vilken utmaning Facebook kan vara för biblioteken. Han menar att Library 2.0-tekniker i princip [...]

  3. Library Views 圖書館觀點 :: 貴館的 Library 2.0 服務算是成功的嗎? :: September :: 2007 - September 28, 2007

    [...] Library 1.0 的思維來執行 2.0 的工具或服務。The Other Librarian 的作者 Ryan Deschamps 就針對許多圖書館開始在 [...]

  4. Facebook…otra vez… « Alusión…Llamada Virtual - October 3, 2007

    [...] Vía Librarian in Black llego al blog The Other Librarian y a su entrada Facebook and Raport.  Me gustó leerlo.  Ultimamente he tenido varias conversaciones entre [...]

  5. links for 2007-10-04 « Social Life of Suburban Spaces - October 3, 2007

    [...] Facebook and Rapport « The Other Librarian (tags: facebook libraries library2.0)   [...]

  6. A Few Things I’m Noticing While I Twitter « The Other Librarian - January 16, 2008

    [...] be used.   And certainly, some libraries are using it.   Still, as I’ve said about the Facebook universe, I strongly feel that we need to come up with tidy, professional-looking ways of using the [...]

  7. Does anyone really want to talk to a librarian? « Libodyssey - March 4, 2008

    [...] Facebook and rapport: Some suggestions on how to involve libraries in social networking without compromising professionalism [...]

  8. What Does This Mean to Me, Laura? » Blog Archive » Facebook and public libraries - August 7, 2008

    [...] Will it hurt to create a Facebook profile for your library?  Very unlikely.  But libraries need to understand that they will be, to some extent, unwanted.  Ryan Deschamps of The Other Librarian says: “So let me start with the Facebook library search application. It is fine, but my opinion is that few people besides librarians are going to add the applications to their profiles. The technology is Web 2.0, but the strategy is still Library 1.0. Why? Because the model is still, “I am librarian. I can help. Come to me (ie. my Facebook page) and I will serve.” The applications, though offering marginally better service for little cost, are not taking advantage of what Facebook offers its clients.” (Source) [...]

  9. Hennepin Public Library « In Your Face, Library book? - December 4, 2008

    [...] Ryan Deschamps of the Other Librarian points out, however, “few people besides librarians are going to add the applications to [...]

  10. So, is Facebook in the library working? « In Your Face, Library book? - December 5, 2008

    [...] Deschamps of The Other Librarian writes about this needed rapport: In the end, the reason students will say they do not want to see [...]

  11. Evaluation of the Social Networking Profiles of Libraries « A Look at Libraries and Social Networking Profiles - April 13, 2009

    [...] customize the profile, and have fun with it!  “The Other Librarian” offered suggestions in a 2007 post such as: develop your own facebook applications, understand the online culture you are becoming a [...]

  12. The Seattle Public Library: Seattle Public Library Home Page « Tanin's Blog - November 26, 2009

    [...] the small size of Monterey (30,161 in 2006), I think the MPL is right in trying to attempt to “establish rapport” with its community through a more intimate and personal engagement via Facebook and Flickr. (See [...]

  13. UW Libraries on Facebook « Tanin's Blog - December 3, 2009

    [...] think The Other Librarian is precise in pointing out the problem of an academic library on Facebook: “In the end, the [...]

  14. Y a quoi de bien sur le net ? (4) | La veille C mon TIC - February 24, 2010

    [...] Facebook and Rapport (sur The Other Librarian) [...]

  15. Demographics « Valuestour's Blog - November 21, 2010

    [...] memory: Successful Facebook Pages, as well as one that we covered in our LIBR500 course, from The Other Librarian.  It looks like Seattle is doing quite well on all regards, given the high number of members and [...]

  16. Sunnyvale, CA Public Library on Facebook: D.O.A.? « Libraries Two-Point-Whoa! - December 5, 2010

    [...] are scores of articles (like this one) and blogs (like this one and this one) that discuss the issue, and debates about whether or not users (usually students) want their [...]

  17. Geoffrey R. Weller Library « l500nugadoy - April 9, 2011

    [...] libraries to engage Facebook requires rapport” This is seen with Geoffrey R. Weller Library Facebook site. Many of the postings have [...]

  18. bladerunner11 - April 10, 2011

    [...] same size as the banner for reference services. As The Other Librarian states in their blog entry Facebook and Rapport, “The Facebook model affirms extroversion.” I don’t blame the VPL for making an attempt [...]

  19. Social Networking and Special Library Collections « iLibris - April 10, 2011

    [...] tools to increase interactivity and visibility of libraries among their communities. However, the Other Librarian states that some insist that “the culture of Libraries clashes with the culture of [...]

  20. “The Social Network” in Libraries « Recent Trends in Library 2.0 - April 11, 2011

    [...] in connecting with users. Noted by Ryan Deschamps a.k.a. the Other Librarian in his article “Facebook and Rapport“, it is not enough for libraries to join Facebook and have patrons come to them but rather [...]

  21. Facebook and Libraries | Social Media Use in Libraries - November 29, 2011

    [...] There is also other literature on how libraries should use Facebook.  Ryan Deschamps’ Other Librarian Blog offers ideas on how Facebook should be used in libraries.  Ryan’s blog states that “Facebook [...]

  22. University Library (Aberdeen) « socmed500 - December 4, 2011

    [...] that they respond to all these complaints. Ryan Deschamps of The Other Librarian said that libraries on Facebook should ask people questions and figure out what they like. I think figuring out what people [...]

  23. Facebook Fitting with Other Services (Multnomah County Library) « mlisestudiante - December 29, 2011

    [...] his blog, The Other Librarian, Ryan Deschamps emphasizes the importance of building rapport in Facebook by reconciling the [...]

  24. La Bibliothèque Africaine : Un réel besoin de marketing - January 2, 2012

    [...] comme disait Other Librarian, dans son billet Facebook and Rapport (à lire), il ne s’agit pas seulement d’utiliser la technologie web 2.0 mais aussi d’adopter une [...]

  25. Post # 2.0 « kblog - April 8, 2012

    [...] they seem to be heading in the right direction towards what “The Other Librarian” calls “building rapport”. While at the time her post was written, she talks more about “friends” and that option [...]

  26. How about Facebook? « michellethoughts - April 10, 2012

    [...] media by the libraries, I chose to see how they are using Facebook.  Ryan Deschamps, in his “The Other Librarian” blog post, recommends an approach for libraries in using Facebook:  “If we approach Facebook [...]

  27. The BPL Facebook Page « biblioguru - April 10, 2012

    [...] if an institution followed their Facebook friends a little too closely. This point is mentioned in The Other Librarian, a wonderful blog by Ryan Deschamps. In his post about Facebook in Libraries, he also argues that [...]

  28. Facebook, une nécessité pour les bibliothèques? | resauxsociauxbibliotheques - January 23, 2013

    [...] comme disait Other Librarian, dans son billet Facebook and Rapport, il ne s’agit pas seulement d’utiliser la technologie web 2.0 mais aussi d’adopter une [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,521 other followers

%d bloggers like this: